On Sunday, we packed nearly four dozen grocery bags to deliver to St. Stephen’s Youth Programs in the South End, to be distributed to families whose kids go to the B-SAFE summer camp there. On Tuesday, we made a hundred roast-beef sandwiches to share for the next day’s lunch. And this Sunday, we’ll hear the gospel story of the loaves and fishes, when Jesus takes five loaves of bread and two fish and somehow feeds a crowd of five thousand, with twelve baskets of leftovers to boot. What good timing!
We sometimes take this “loaves and fishes” story as an example of charitable generosity. (I couldn’t tell you how many church food pantries are named “Loaves and Fishes,” but there are hundreds of them around) But that’s not quite the point. It’s not a food pantry story; it’s not about the disciples distributing life’s necessities to the hungry and poor. Jesus has no food. The disciples have no food. And the large crowd who’ve gathered aren’t poor or hungry or downtrodden. They’re just a crowd who are so excited to be following Jesus that they, too, have forgotten to bring any food.
Except for one young boy with “five barley loaves and two fish.” (John 6:9)
This is the key detail that’s often overlooked. The food isn’t handed out from above. It’s not trucked in by do-gooders from a far-off, better-off place. It’s shared by a child in the crowd. There’s no institution behind it, no program, not even any foresight. There’s just the exuberant, generous chaos that begins when someone is willing to share what they have with their neighbors, as equals, when they need it. This act of generosity doesn’t create divisions between the haves and the haven-nots; it creates community instead.
There’s been a live conversation in the last few years about whether “charity” is helpful or harmful, compassionate or condescending. (You can read books like Toxic Charity or When Helping Hurts if you want to find out more.) But at its best, this work can be more like the young boy’s gift: an open act of sharing to a neighbor in a time of need, as part of a longer-term relationship.
So thank you, all of you who gave or shopped or worked this week! Thank you for being partners with Episcopal churches in Boston and beyond, and for being neighbors to your fellow Bostonians. Thank you for your generosity; but thank you, more than anything, for recognizing that what we have is not ours to hold onto when others are in need, but only ours to share.